17

Harsh Mehta - 1992 Scam - Our Learnings

Hello fellow investors

Ishq hai, toh Risk hai!! Today, I am going to talk about the most acclaimed show of the Indian network currently - Harshad Mehta - 1992 Scam. Don't worry I am not going to give any spoilers. Through this article, it is my attempt to share the learnings about investing that we all can take home and apply.

Harshad Mehta, a name which is could be new to many young investors but is the reason why my father moved to Bombay and took up finance as his profession. He was the living God for many young investors back in 1992 and he also helped many people make money in the market. However, when the basis of his work and reality came to light, he also became the reason for many people losing their entire life savings. 

 


Let's check out the learnings you budding investors can take from the show:

  1. The 3 main fundamentals of investing in the stock market are 1. Have common sense 2. Do research on the fundamentals of the company 3. Do not underestimate how behavior and investors' confidence changes the tides of the market.
  2. The entire show in fact focuses on the fact that the blinding trust of people in Harshad made them buy stocks of companies he was buying even where some of the companies had no business or value. Never just invest in tips + articles - Do your own research, it is your money. 
  3. Fear of missing out (FOMO) can lead to higher losses if not managed properly. You need to be able to control your emotions. Buying when the market is going up in the fear of missing out could make you lose more money. Buy when the price is right, not because everyone else is buying.
  4. When you invest on the basis of a tip from anyone you are gambling in the market, playing your chances not really investing any money on fundamentals.
  5. No one is the god of the market, the market waits and listens to nobody, there are many players and forces that make the market move, and having a proper process which guides you when to enter and when to leave will help you manage your risk of investing. One such process is asset allocation. We have written many articles to explain how this process helps you overcome your fear and FOMO and invest as per your risk-taking capacity.
  6. Equity Investing is RISKY and has always been but over time, various financial institutions and SEBI has better control to protect the interest of investors, having said that there have been many crashes after 1992 which are beyond our control (including the one in March 2020). One thing to remember as an investor is a market high in 1992 was 4000 and 2020 was 40,000. After every crash, the market does bounce back, all you have to do is give it time. Hence, the key to success in Equity Investing has always been Long term !!
  7. There will always be another market crash around us waiting to happen, we can never time that or control. As investors what you and I can control is our learnings, investing basis true fundamentals, and building a balanced portfolio that is designed based on goals and asset allocation, phir Harshad Aaye ya corona, Hume Nahi koi Rona Dhona.

This was a small email with some very detailed take-aways. Do enjoy the show, there are so many things to learn from it and I could not feel more proud to be a part of the time and space where Indian television is making shows which highlight the importance of financial literacy. The main learning from the entire show is that we must know how to manage our money, we must be financially aware so that no one can take any undue advantage of us and our money.

On this note of learning and becoming more aware, I want to inform you that we are coming out soon with our new course on money management - Namaste Money only for you - newbie investors. This will be a detailed online course where we will teach you everything from debt and equity to mutual funds to asset allocation. All our days and nights are going into finalizing the content of this course and opening it for registration. You can read all about 1this course here. Don't forget to give us your feedback.

 

Disclaimer: - The articles are for information purposes only. Information presented is general information that does not take into account your individual circumstances, financial situation, or needs, nor does it present a personalized recommendation to you. You must consult a financial advisor who understands your specific circumstances and situation before taking an investment decision.



david-paschke-72432-unsplash (1)

Insurance Frauds and Spurious calls

A friend was duped into buying a Private Company's life insurance policy when she had just started to work with her first employer. Being new to tax planning, she was sold the policy stating that payment of INR 50,000 per annum for the next 7 years will get her INR 1,000,000 at the end of 15 years.

The friend got a call on her landline asking for her insurance needs. Her mother gave her mobile number to the insurance agent and asked her to coordinate with him. She was so occupied at work that she bought whatever insurance he sold to her convincing her that the investment would double in 7 years and the insurance will also give her tax benefits.

When any salaried individual hears - 'Tax benefit', they jump into that investment without really thinking if this is going to give any actual tax benefit.

We have in detail discussed in our Article – Why you must buy a term Insurance and mutual funds av/s a general endowment plan. The article explains with examples how commonly bought insurance from any insurance company does not give a return of more than 6%. Whereas a mutual fund gives you a return of 9-15%.

I went with my friend to surrender the policy at the HDFC Insurance office and was surprised to see that around 10 people were waiting to surrender their insurance policy on a Friday afternoon.

Why are the policies missold

The Insurance agents get a commission ranging from 40% to 70% on the premium amount paid towards insurance making insurance the most marketed financial product in the world.

This commission is just not for the first-year premium. In some cases, they get it for the first 3 years 40% and the balance 3 years 20%.

The high commission makes insurance a very lucrative product to sell.

New ways of miss-selling

The case of misselling has worsened since people have started getting spurious calls in the name of regulatory organizations and government or quasi-government authorities. Recently some gangs have been exposed to a new scam in the Insurance Sector “Fake calls from IRDA”.

This scam is to trap the existing policyholders who are not satisfied with their existing plan and are not getting desired returns, bonuses, or claims.

  • They get calls from people pretending to be representatives of IRDA.
  • They claim that this call is on behalf of IRDA to address the complaints and grievances of the policyholder.
  • The person receiving such a phone call gets convinced and starts sharing the problems faced with the existing insurance policy.
  • On understanding the issue of the policyholders, these tele-callers convince that they will get a refund of the existing policy and the policyholder can withdraw the actual amount of the premium paid to the company.
  • These callers, the fake IRDA representatives, keep complete knowledge about the functioning of insurance companies, regulatory authority, and norms and then they make the other person convinced confidently and smartly with their conversation.

I have also received calls from IRDA asking if I had any issues or I should own a good insurance product. They are regulatory bodies and hence, it is very easy for people to believe them.

When I told them to send me an email, they started abusing me over the phone and spoke in a very disgusting manner. I immediately knew that they are imposters and cut the call.

How can you protect yourself from such spurious calls?

  1. Do not entertain any insurance provider over a phone call; always ask them to drop an email from their official email ID, providing you with the offer and other details.
  2. It is very important to educate your parents about the same. It is very easy to obtain the landline numbers and sell the same to housewives with little or no knowledge about these calls. They end up giving their debit card/credit card pins.
  3. Report all the telephone numbers when you receive a call from one, claiming to be a fake LIC agent or the IRDA regulators.
  4. IRDA has issued a public notice to state that the regulator (i.e IRDA) never makes any calls. "The general public is hereby informed that the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority is a regulatory body which does not involve directly or through any representative in a sale of any kind of insurance or financial products," a public notice posted on its website said. It further adds that if you make any kind of transaction with such a fake agent, you would be doing so at your own risk.
  5. Likewise, if you receive calls from an agent claiming to be from LIC or any other insurance company for that matter, it's best to disconnect the call.
  6. If an agent asks you to pay cash, it should be an immediate red flag. According to LIC's advertisement, when you buy a LIC policy, you should register the same on their portal for easier management of the policy.
  7. When an agent visits you, you should check his/her license, issued by the insurance company. But, then, we think it isn't too difficult for fraudsters to make fake licenses. So, maybe paying a visit to the insurer’s branch office or buying a policy online via the company's website or online insurance portal, would work better.
  8. Register your policies online on the websites and other private insurers to avoid any communication with an agent. You can coordinate with the insurance providers over email.
  9. Make use of 15 days /30 days free-look period and read all the policy documents after you have received the same.

These are basic solutions and common sense ways to deal with the problem of spurious calls. However, as many of us are too occupied with work and other commitments, we do not spend too much time sorting our investments becoming prey to such scams.

It is your hard-earned money that is being invested in various financial products and hence, you must be cautious on how you manage the same.

 

To learn more - you can check our course - NM 102: Build a Safety Net. Use code SAVE20 for 20% off.

 

    Get your weekly dose of Money Masala from us.


    4d619a3a7f3c24b8c4bdb9cdd8d7fc40_agenda-analysis-business-990818-2500-c-90

    Why you should not buy financial products from your banker?

    The simplest answer to this question is that, more often than not, the banker is more interested in the product than he is interested in you. To illustrate this better, we have discussed a few examples below: Say you have been a customer of a particular bank from 2008 tillBelow is what you would have typically experienced over this period of time. Your first job, 2010: Sir, along with your salary account, we are offering you a credit card, free of cost. There will be no annual charges and you can enjoy a credit limit of INR 50,000. Along with this we are offering you this "Investment product" which gives higher than market returns, especially for our customers. To make it easy for you, you can pay the yearly premium in 12 equal interest free installments using the credit card. (With this, he introduces you to the world of credit cards plus has latched you on to an investment product mostly a ULIP product (link on ULIP article) without you properly understanding the product. What he doesn't tell you is the charges involved in delayed payments on the credit card, neither does he guide you as to how you can be a disciplined credit card user!) 2008, with the markets soaring or currently when the markets are doing  very well: "Sir, XYZ Mutual Fund has come out with a New Fund Offer (NFO). The new Fund promises very good returns since they are focusing on the Infrastructure theme which will give very high returns over the next few years." "Sir, ABC Mutual Fund has come out with a New Fund Offer (NFO). The new Fund promises very good returns since they have a "new strategy" where they will identify "superior growth" stocks and generate superior returns." (What he doesn't tell you is the risks involved in investing in equities and that he is selling you a product which doesn't have any track record of good returns!)
                                                                                                                                           Take an informed decision
    Immediately after the 2008 crash: A period of silence from your banker. Obviously, he doesn't want to bring up the returns from the ULIPs and NFOs he sold to you earlier in the year! 2009, post ban of entry loads on MFs: Sir, this is a unique investment product. It not only gives you high returns by investing in Equities, it also gives you an insurance cover. (What he doesn't tell you is that ULIPs hardly take care of your insurance requirements. Neither does he elaborate on the various charges on the ULIP products!) 2010, post reduction in commissions on ULIPs: Sir, you should invest in this product. If you invest INR 25,000 per year you will get INR 13,70,000 tax free after 25 years and also an insurance cover of INR 10,00,000. (What he doesn't tell you is that the rate of return is a partly 6%!) I guess many of you (irrespective of your age group!) will be able to relate to the above experience. It clearly demonstrates that your banker is more interested in selling the product that earns him the maximum returns with no consideration to what is the right product for you. He sees the immediate short term benefits for himself from the sales made to you. Why think like your banker and look at the short term? Think long term. Hire a Financial Planner, pay him a fee to give you the right advice and invest in the right investment product. Over a period of time, the benefits from investing in the right financial product far exceed the fees you pay your Financial Planner. Again, think long term. Educate yourself! It is very important in today's time, when there is a pool of information everywhere but no good data, learn and understand and take an informed decision, rather than just following someone blindly. It is your money, if you will not treat it right, why would a banker do that. PS: There can be exceptions to the above kind of bankers. But, more often than not, the story is the same everywhere.

    [mc4wp_form id="2150"]

    WCafe Financial Services Pvt Ltd (formerly known as Wealth Cafe Financial Services Pvt Ltd) is a AMFI registered ARN holder with ARN-78274.

    WCafe Financial Services Pvt Ltd (formerly known as Wealth Cafe Financial Services Pvt Ltd) is a SEBI registered Authorised Person (sub broker) of Sharekhan Limited with NSE Regn AP2069583763 and BSE Regn AP01074801170742.

    Copyright 2010-20 Wealth Café ©  All Rights Reserved